Athersley Rec won 2-1 at home to Selby Town who played with ten men for more than 90 minutes in a game of two missed penalties.
The visitors had a man sent off in the first minute then scored a penalty in the fourth, before missing another in the second half.
Keenan Davies-Mosley levelled midway through the second half then, just after Rec missed a penalty of their own, James Woodhouse won it in the 88th minute.
Rec are now due to visit Crowle Colts on Saturday.
Dearne and District have followed their opening day loss with three straight wins and clean sheets.
Their latest victory saw them beat visitors Appleby Frodingham 2-0 on Saturday thanks to late goals by Curtis Wilkinson and Taylor Nicholson.
They are now due to visit Leeds UFCA on Saturday.
Worsbrough Bridge made it back-to-back wins with a 2-1 success at Nostell MW.
Jake Squires and Connor Glavin netted within minutes of each other midway through the second half before the hosts replied then had a man sent off.
Bridge are now due to host South Leeds on Saturday.
